“ Great service and amazing pizza it's my favorite pizza in the area and I highly recommend!! ”

“ Perfect thin crust pizza slices at a great price. One piece is big! Very friendly people. ”

“ Enjoyed it so much we went back a second day over a three day span. We have a lot of pizza in my hometown, but not this specific type of pizza. This kind of pizza means it's available by the slice, with a crunchy crust, and generous toppings with the right amount of cheese. It means that the slice your order is gonna be thrown back in the oven for a couple extra minutes to warm it up. It means the people behind the counter are known nonsense and expect you to know a thing or two about the product. It means replicating which you would have in Manhattan. This place gets all of the important things right, and the product is delicious. The decor is not fancy, and it's not supposed to be. This is a pizza stand and the food is what counts. I ordered the traditional white pie, as well as their barbecue chicken. Both were magnificent. If I'm ever back in town I'm definitely coming back. ”

“ Small store with limited space and good ambiance (saw many localities picking up slices and having them in parking lot in their cars) During our recent visit to Buffalo, NY, we were looking for a quick dinner and decided to try Joe's Ny Style Pizza after finding out that Broadway NY Style Pizza was closed on Tuesdays. But the reviews were great so we came to Broadway NY Style Pizza on our way back to California. Loved the pizza, we ordered 2 Cheese Pizza, one with onion topping and another w/o any topping (even sauce as wanted to avoid garlic for few family members). There so many pizzas over the counter, next time will try them by slices than whole large pizza. Lady at counter was very friendly and made special pizza w/o garlic which was great and they charged what was shown on the menu (not like Joe's NYC Style Pizza where they move convenience fees on consumer w/o letting them know) will definitely visit this place when travelling to Buffalo, NY. ”

“ January 2024. This is one of my favorite pizza places. The owners and family are from NYC, and the area desperately needed some good NY style pizza. Walking in, there's a showcase of pizzas with different flavors and toppings, along with some rolls, calzones, and sometimes garlic knots and more. They're fully cooked slices, and they do get heated up when you order (or you can choose not to). All pizzas are made fresh daily. Between my multiple visits here, I'm always greeted by whomever is working at the front counter. Philly Pizza 10/10 One of my top 2 favorite pizzas they have. The shaved steak combination with the melted cheese is so delicious, and when you get those peppers and mushrooms in the bite it's even better. Buffalo Chicken 10/10 My other favorite in the top 2. This Buffalo chicken pizza is one of my faves in the area. Even over wegmans! It's your typical Buffalo chicken pizza, nothing crazy to describe here. Pickle Pizza 9/10 Pickle chips with a creamy ranch drizzle. Cooking the pickles does make the saltiness come out a bit, but that's too be expected. Think of a deep fried pickle without the breading. The ranch drizzle isn't overpowering flavor wise either. A good slice. Cheese & Pep 10/10 The regular pepperoni (not cup and char). This pizza is really good. Super authentic NY style, the red sauce is a good flavor, the perfect balance between sweet and robust. The cheese is a little thinner, plenty of pepperonis, and of course all the grease you would want. ”

“ Being from NJ, we expect A LOT from our pizza. We are ALWAYS leary of "NY Style" pizza even in NY‍ Being in Niagara Falls for the weekend, we were soon famished for something to eat. We were just going to grab a Five Guys Burger, when we happened across "You've tried the rest, now try the best!" flyer from Broadway NY Style Pizza. We were there late on a Sunday evening, so the cases did not have a lot to offer. We went with plain cheese slices. Oh.my.word so good. We were very pleased to say the least. Hot, crispy, cheesy, melty goodness so far from home Thank you Broadway for being a home away from . ”

“ Absolutely freaking delicious pizza. This is just what we were looking for, nice greasy New York style pizza. The kind that hangs over the plate. My shirt is ruined from Greece, but I don't care because it was so freaking good. ”

“ As soon as I walked into the pizzeria, the aroma of the pizza hit me, and I knew I was at the right place. Since I am not from here, I decided to try the pizzeria closest to my hotel. I was pleased to receive an immediate greeting upon entering. The menu was displayed on screens above, and everything looked enticing, including the burgers, pasta and appetizers. However, I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, which turned out to be delicio, from the crust to the sauce! ”

“ Authentic, NY style pizza!! My soccer team was in New York for a game and we were craving some pizza. One of the parents had been to Broadway on a prior trip and spoke very highly of it. We called and asked if they could seat 13 of us; they said no problem. They actually started cooking our order and had a table set up and ready for us when we arrived. As a group, we stuck to the basics: a couple cheese pies, and a couple pepperoni pies. However, they have a variety of specialty pizzas to choose from as well. One guy with us tried a slice of pickle pizza and he said it was really good. You can order full pies or by the slice. I definitely had to fold my slices to eat. They were delicious. Broadway Pizza is only about 20 minutes from Niagara Falls. It is not a full sized restaurant, but they do have several tables to eat inside and you can push them together to serve a large group. Both bottle drinks and fountain drinks are available. The service was excellent; the employees very nice and accommodating. If you in the area and looking for some authentic NY style pizza, I highly recommend Broadway Pizza! ”